Coverage that Fits

Shopping for insurance online can leave you unprotected or underinsured. The insurance professionals at Mayville Tremaine Inc. will work with you to find the coverage and pricing tailored to fit your needs.
Get Started Now

Why Mayville Tremaine?

Mayville Tremaine Inc. is proud of its history of helping customers protect their assets since 1913.  We can match you with an insurance professional who is knowledgeable, experienced, and will find the best insurance solution.

 

We believe that a personal relationship is essential to ensure our customers are properly protected. We will be with you every step of the way from securing a new policy to assisting you during the claims process.

Contact Us Now
Slone Melhuish Logo

Personal Lines

Our personal lines staff can help ensure your assets are protected. We will shop your insurance needs across our network of insurance companies and find you the right coverage at the right price.

  • Homeowners
  • Automobile
  • Umbrella
  • Landlords
  • Motorcycle
  • Watercraft
Slone Melhuish Logo

Commercial Lines

You can rely on the experience and knowledge of our commercial lines staff to properly insure your business needs. From straightforward to hard to place risks, we can find you a policy you can trust.

  • Automobile
  • Business Owners
  • General Liability
  • Property
  • Workers Compensation
  • Umbrella
Slone Melhuish Logo

Claims Department

Our claims department staff is committed to helping you navigate the claims process. We will be with you every step of the way from claims reporting to claim resolution.

Meet the Team

Our experienced staff is ready to assist you with all your insurance needs. Feel free to contact us any time or visit us at any of our three locations Mondays through Fridays 8:00AM to 4:30PM.

Profile Picture for Michele Aguilar

Michele Aguilar

Personal Lines

(716)672-2153 ext. 215

Email

Profile Picture for Stefanie Burns

Stefanie Burns

Personal Lines

(716)753-7135 ext. 216

Email

Profile Picture for Derek Dawson

Derek Dawson

Commercial Lines

(716)672-2153 ext. 212

Email

Profile Picture for Randy Graham

Randy Graham

Commercial Lines

(716)483-1591 ext. 3008

Email

Profile Picture for Patty Johnson

Patty Johnson

Claims

(716)483-1591 ext. 3019

Email

Profile Picture for JoAnn Murray

JoAnn Murray

Personal Lines

(716)483-1591 ext. 3006

Email

Profile Picture for Jon Stahley

Jon Stahley

Claims

(716)483-1591 ext. 3022

Email

Profile Picture for Gigi Whitaker

Gigi Whitaker

Commercial Lines

(716)672-2153 ext. 214

Email